A major league pitcher dreams of throwing a perfect game. High schoolers eyeing the Ivy League study furiously in hopes of earning 2400 on the SAT. Meanwhile, Chris Peplinski is pursuing his own brand of flawlessness: an 850 credit score.
The 37-year-old stay-at-home dad from Rogers, Ark., has nabbed 813 on the FICO scale, the credit scoring system most lenders use in sizing up potential borrowers.
That ranks him above more than 82 percent of Americans and comes with a big payoff: It entitles him to ultralow rates on loans, saving him tens of thousands of bucks over a lifetime.
Nevertheless, Peplinski won't be satisfied until he hits the maximum: 850. Why?
"Your credit score tells a lot about you," Peplinski said. "A high score means you're responsible and in control of your life. You're trustworthy."
To reach his goal, Peplinski voraciously reads up on every element that goes into a FICO score, checks his number every three months and tweaks his behavior to eke out every possible additional point.
Two years ago, he took out a car loan even though he and his wife, Chrissy, had the cash to buy their wheels outright. He figured that adding to his mix of credit might boost his score.
In spite of Chris' best efforts, landing an 850 may be a quixotic goal: Only about 0.5 percent of Americans manage it, FICO reports.
"The 850 score is kind of like a unicorn," said John Ulzheimer, a credit scoring expert with Credit.com who used to work for FICO. "Everybody talks about it, but nobody's seen it."
The reality is that you don't need to catch the unicorn to catch the best rates. But adopting some of the habits of members of the 800 club can help you improve your own score.
And that can translate into real money: On a $300,000, 30-year fixed-rate mortgage, the most creditworthy borrowers will pay $14,200 less than those one tier below; $25,600 less than those two tiers below.
But as for exactly how many points you'll gain or lose for, say, taking on a mortgage, being late on a bill or charging credit cards up to the max? That's proprietary information: "It's a black box," said FICO spokesman Craig Watts.
Mystery feeds obsession. Some credit score aficionados passionately debate their hypotheses on message boards like the FICO Forums at myfico.com. Others use themselves as guinea pigs to discover which moves will nudge a score up or down.
Some check their score obsessively, at least every few months, at a cost of $50 or more a year. They also fixate on their credit reports, upon which the scores are based.
Leland Lim, a 41-year-old doctor from northern California, is vigilant about scanning these for errors that might drag down his number.
"It took me three years to get a derogatory entry on one of them corrected," said Lim, who now earns an 806.
As for what makes an 800-plus score, these self-made experts basically say the same thing FICO does: Payment history is the single most important factor.
"I have this fetish about paying bills as soon as they come in the house," said Dick Husemann, 66, a retired Air Force officer from Wilmington, N.C. He and his wife, Brenda, 69, attribute their high scores, matching 818s, to the fact that they've never missed a credit payment.
The Husemanns also never charge more than 10 percent of their credit limit. They're not alone in that: Most score enthusiasts aim to keep a low "utilization ratio," or the amount they owe compared with the amount of credit available to them. FICO verifies that a low ratio can help your score.
With lenders routinely closing inactive accounts, Lim rotates all his credit cards into circulation so that he'll continue to have a lot of available credit to figure into his utilization ratio.
But because his charges also affect that ratio, a few months before applying for a loan he stops using the cards or pays them off before the statement is generated. That way, Lim said, "my score jumps a bit," just in time for the lender to see.
The 800 club members are also conscious of their mix of credit.
Lim became interested in the scoring process two years ago while refinancing a home-equity loan into a home-equity line of credit. Having heard that revolving debt could affect a score more than an installment loan, he studied up.
His research revealed that home-equity lines of credit are not considered revolving debt in the FICO model. (The scoring firm confirms this.) And remember that car loan Peplinski took out, even though he didn't have to? He did it because FICO favors those with a variety of credit types, such as mortgage, credit cards and auto loans.
"I probably paid $100 in interest," he said. "But it was worth it because we raised our credit scores by 15 points."